The Three Forgotten Stoners from Flint
They were never really embraced by the east and west coast intelligentsia. Rolling Stone magazine wasn’t a friend to the band, nor was the hip alternative magazine from their home state, Cream. Their sound was a throbbing monolith, built on a pure, primitive drive that was closer to a voodoo ceremony than a peace happening. This wasn’t the Grateful Dead. Although, I understand that small tabs of “blue micro-dot” weren’t uncommon. I call the rag-tag power trio from Flint, the forgotten (grand)fathers of Desert Rock with their pumping bass and shouted vocals. But maybe we are getting ahead of ourselves. Let us consider the background a bit.
The landscape of the city of Flint, Michigan is about as different from the origins of the Palm Desert Scene as you could imagine. Cement structures replace the open landscapes that inspired Josh Homme and company. If ever there was a doomed place in the post-industrial American empire, it is the city of Flint, a city nearly as forgotten as our still un-named band of midwestern stoners. Located north of the city of Detroit, Flint was nicknamed “Vehicle City” because of the massive amount of automobiles produced there after WWII. Flint was the symbol of a prospering nation until the early 80s recession hit and destroyed this illusion of the American Dream. The largest maker of car’s in the world, General Motors, downsized their workforce in Flint from 80,000 in 1978 to under 8,000 today. However you feel about the US Empire, you need to consider the individual economic heartbreak and despair that resulted in Flint losing half the population between during the same period.
Which bring us to Grand Trunk Western Railroad. Today Grand Truck Railroad is the American subsidiary of Canadian National Railway. But originally, Grand Trunk Railroad was born from a collection of rail lines going back to the early 19th century. The railroad’s presence in Detroit and throughout the nation made Grand Truck an essential link in the growth of the auto-industry with manufacturing plants across the state. Which is how our band of brothers got their name, the obvious word-play of Grand Funk Railroad. So let us get back on… track.
It’s hard to image today, but in 1971 GFR sold out New York’s Shea Stadium faster than any other band, including the Fabulously Overrated Four. With 10 platinum albums in a row, it’s odd that Grand Funk Railroad have been left behind by classic rock fans who are endlessly loyal to every super deluxe reissue by Led Zeppelin or, God help me, Deep Purple. But music isn’t just about selling records, it’s about understanding the connectivity of ideas and art and acknowledging how music develops from one generation and the next. Even Rolling Stone magazine noted that the Josh Homme fronted Queens of the Stone Age had a connection between “American meat-and-potatoes macho rock of the early 1970s, like Blue Cheer and Grand Funk Railroad, and the precision-timing drones in German rock of the same period”. Time for us to reconsider the music of that forgotten power-trio of Mark, Don and Mel.
At their best, which almost always means in-concert recordings, Grand Funk Railroad was a massive beast of raw energy and heat. It’s not a metallic sound, not even hard-rock in the traditional sense of the word. The energy, sweat and groove was born of the same contempt, boredom and frustration that had inspired the desert rock sound in the late 80s and 90s. And while it is Black Sabbath that is so often cited as the inspiration of the desert sound, the raging groove of Grand Funk Railroad is the missing link in that sound. It’s not studied. They don’t give out diplomas for the music ritual of the Palm Desert Scene. You can’t even really capture the sound on vinyl, it’s the power of performance, when music becomes primitive and sophisticated, when you must live within the sound. There may not be much of a structured song once the drum and bass lock into place.
When it comes to desert groove, no record on earth will change your life faster than Welcome to Sky Valley by Kyuss, the most important hard-rock album of the 90s. A collection of tracks with lots of groove to spare. That “groove” is apparently elusive for some rock-music critics to identify when it’s within the context of hard or heavy music. It’s possible they don’t really understand the definition. Here we try to help. Groove is raw, primal, communal and often sexual. There is nothing in the world like watching a powerful band lock in sync with the crowd or audience. With Kyuss or Hawkwind, locked-groove disintegrates into pure white-noise, the shouted vocal and guitar becoming one with the rhythm. A wall of sound that forces you to move your ass. It’s irresistible. And when you are ready to explore that sound further, don’t forget about the missing link from Flint, Michigan: Grand Funk Railroad. Their second album, Grand Funk, commonly know as the “Red” album, and Live Album (1970) are as vital as Black Sabbath’s Master of Reality or Volume 4 to the development of the desert sound. One last note and let’s be clear here: The endorsement of GFR is limited to their first few albums. Unfortunately, the bulk of their albums are plagued by inconsistency and mediocrity, taking forays into soft rock and cover-song territory. Anyone need to hear the Locomotion again? Nevertheless, on the Live Album/Red, Grand Funk add, with smoking playing and groove, an important layer in the history of hard rock music.
by Shawn Ciavattone
They will never be forgotten here at HOME !!
I remember Mark I was young he lived on Davison rd center rd in flint they would practice in little garage I would sneak over n watch him play got grounded couple times when parents found out as life gos on I bought a house on Coldwater rd near Dort hwy in front off my house marks father was hit n killed by the train I always wonder if that was how grand funk railroad got there name till this day I still listen to there music I have most off his album lot off history for me this was 1 off my favorite songs till this day
It’s Creem magazine, not Cream.
Shawn, your article and your comments after really hit the nail on the head about the legacy of GFR. Very well done!
Thank you kindly for your comments, Wayne. I grew up with the sound of GFR blasting from a neighbors 8-track player every Saturday morning. The sweet smell of low-grade marijuana filling the air. But it’s more than nostalgia. Inside looking out, Paranoid and Got This Thing On The Move…all played an important role in the development of a unique sound.
I was born and raised in Flint.
Your article needs to get more public recognition.
It’s like the sins of the fathers of Flint will be paid for by the children of the city of Flint.
While I agree the Red album and first Live album are their best, I wouldn’t exclude their later works completely, except after Shinin’ On. E Pluribus Unum is a fantastic album, and their covers of Gimme Shelter and Feelin’ Alright are exceptional. As far as the Locomotion, I’d agree if it weren’t for the scorching guitar solo, and if any rock band was meant to cover it, it was Grand Funk Railroad. So I got that. Yes, they gravitated towards a more commercial sound, until they lost themselves, but they were a great influence for a good decade. Now I have to research desert rock and Kyuss. Great read!
I bet those shows in Nashville were worth remembering. And I agree that Grand Funk continued to make worthwhile music after their initial period. However, it was that early, raw phase that was influential. Those early performances and albums were drenched with sweaty, primal groove. Certainly good songs (I’m Your Captain, for example) continued but the music lacked the youthful creative lust. Watch the video clip below and see a transformation from rock concert to tribal ceremony. GFR was more then a good rock band with kick-ass songs at that point. For a brief period Mark, Mel & Don tapped into a rarefied musical ritual. The same atmosphere of the MC5 or the Stooges or Sun Ra. The band gathered at the crossroads and shared their stage with gods and demons. The audience was transported. Anyway, thank you for your comments. Enjoy exploring the Desert Rock scene. Kyuss is the place to start.
Your article is too opinionated. Overrated fab 4 , Taking shots and Zep and Deep Purple. You even discard later loved Funk albums. I found it a article plastered with negativity. Are you sure you don’t write for Rolling Stone?
I saw Grand Funk at perhaps their 2nd or 3rd public performance in Nashville in 1969 and became a life-long fan. The band got screwed by their manager then Mark Farner got screwed by his bandmates. No Farner, No Funk. Their live album is the best live album of all time. When they regroup temporarily in the 1990s, they were on the Top 10 concert attendance list and in their prime in the early ’70s, their records sales outpaced Zeppelin. The fact that they are not in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame is alone proof that it is a sham.
Nevertheless, the heat and energy that was created on stage between those three young men and the audience was and remains. Their art endures and the ceremony between them can never be taken. The participants understand. The groove and sweat was real. Fuck the Rock Hall of Fame and their fake elitist awards. GFR was more than that. Let’s celebrate their ritual.
they were the biggest band in america in 1971, had there own jet. selling out every arena in the country and in abroad. it was a forgotten time in music history.
There influence has been, unfortunately, overlooked. Nevertheless, GF was the real deal.
Forgotten? They sold MILLIONS of records.
It’s not the numbers of albums sold. The point is – GF created a unique sound that has influenced other bands. Maybe you aren’t familiar with an important aspect of the article; the 90s Stoner or Desert Rock sound and scene. A little independent research may be helpful.
This band was the 70s. Good times…
Good times, I’m sure. And also the development of a unique sound the influenced an entire music scene decades later.
Their bass player is UNREAL!
Mel Schacher is simply the best rock bassist of all time
That bass is a lethal weapon. 💣
No seatbelts!
Great read. I also never heard of them, but thoroughly enjoyed reading this!
Thank you for your comment. I’d start with the Red album. 70s hard groove!
They are excellent!! SO great to read about them 👏
Thank you for your comments.
Shawn,
Agreed with you that the groove is key in the history of hard rock–bands you’ve mentioned such as Black Sabbath (their debut, Paranoid, Master of Reality), Blue Cheer (Outsideinside), Hawkwind (their debut, In Search of Space, Space Ritual, Hall of the Mountain Grill) during that heady era of the late 1960s/early 1970s and more recently bands such as Kyuss (Blues for the Red Sun and Welcome to Sky Valley are desert rock masterpieces) and Monster Magnet (they covered Grand Funk Railroad on their stoner metal debut Spine of God) all share this heavy psych groove.
Grand Funk Railroad, as you said, is mentioned less because they’re more associated with their radio hits than their hard rock side.
Mark, those are all desert island albums. No doubt. Not many can approach hard rock music with the uniqueness and intensity of the bands and albums mentioned. GF found their own muscular groove for a few short albums. Proving that some working class kids from Flint, Michigan could climb to those amazing heights.
Hugely informative article, didn’t know anything about the Grand Funk Railroad.. Thanks Shawn
Thank you Octavio. Something a little different from my home state. Was a big part of my high-school years.
I agree, it’s strange that Grand Funk Railroad is somewhat excluded from the canon nowadays. They do not get the credit that they deserve. Awesome band!
Many factors seemed to contribute to Grand Funk getting overlooked. Some of it their own doing. The pop singles. The cover-versions. Those songs kept the gravytrain going but hurt their legacy.
Vietnam
Vietnam and marijuana seemed to be their issues.
One of the tightest rock bands you will ever hear. They set a lot of precedents but don’t get acknowledged for it. Great write-up!
Thank you. “Tight but loose” was the description people gave Percy and company. But it’s fits GF much better indeed.
They were playing like it was their first and last show 🎸⚡
Well stated! There is an urgency to the music. It’s had to come out for both the musicians and their audience.
I love such informative and connecting articles, and I especially love this one because I have never heard of GFR before, and so the article has an exciting introductionary quality for me. I do worship Kyuss and all their records unconditionally, and I agree on that they did the most important rock record of the 90s. Love your mention of “contempt, boredom, and frustration” as inspiration for great creativity and art, especially for artists with a working class background like the Sabbath boys (life is just more boring when poor…). The Kyuss records are all about that boredom and frustration which make the spirit wander and create. They are the soundtrack to watch a lizard or the psychedelic haze and shimmer of a melting street on a hot day, for hours and hours. Creating a primal force with elaborate nuance in the vast monotony of the desert, a concept which has equivalents in introspective and slow cinema. Anyway, this is not about Kyuss 😉 Thanks for this article, I will finally listen to some GFR live recordings .
Grand Funk Railroad rips!
Your comment is more insightful than my article. And I love it. I’m so pleased you enjoyed this little connection between Grand Funk Railroad and Kyuss. I grew up with We’re an American Band blasting through every high school party but it’s those early GF albums that have stuck to the bone. And, in my opinion, they have aged brilliantly. All that beautiful, violent rebellion before it was distorted by politics. Youthful menace. The connection makes me appreciate Homme’s and company even more. If that’s possible. Take an hour one sunny afternoon and blast the Live album. It’s good for the soul.